Now Microsoft Wants Its Laptop Back

57 Comments 12.27.06

Microsoft and AMD sent out a pile of very expensive (yet trashy looking) laptops to a number of bloggers over the past week. We were told we could keep them – now after a day of minor outrage by some people they are emailing us back with the following request that we not keep them after all! And to think, I almost smashed mine in the middle of the street 10 minutes into trying to use it! I did figure out some of the basics after awhile, but it’s still nothing life changing. Ok, so obviously I’m being a bit snotty here and am in a position of ridiculous privilege to get one of these things for free – I just don’t think it’s anything to get your knickers in a twist about given the state of the world.

My point is: the PR backpedal here is just silly. The original email read” “you are welcome to send the machine back to us after you are done playing with it, or you can give it away to your community, or you can hold onto it for as long as you’d like.” Now this follow up:

Marshall,

No good deed goes unpunished, right? You may have seen that other bloggers got review machines as well. Some of that coverage was not factual. As you write your review I just wanted to emphasize that this is a review pc. I strongly recommend you disclose that we sent you this machine for review, and I hope you give your honest opinions. Just to make sure there is no misunderstanding of our intentions I’m going to ask that you either give the pc away or send it back when you no longer need it for product reviews.

Thanks for your understanding, and happy reviewing,

Aaron ***

Ha ha ha – the snazzy laptop I got in the mail from Microsoft yesterday was the only way I was ever going to use Vista anyway. And I’m certainly never going to take a laptop with a stupid looking Ferrari logo on the front anywhere but home and my cube at work.

The computer itself doesn’t retail for $2k plus for nothing – it’s fast. Windows is so annoying and (to me, a Mac user) so counter-intuitive, that I’d never buy a Windows machine. My partner won’t touch the thing. I’m going to set it up to look pretty, take incoming news as if it was the 2nd half of a super large monitor and work on my Mac. Not that I’m super happy with the crash-happy, Flash-hating Macbook I have either. (That said, Parallels is a great program for testing Windows only applications.) See also oops – no new podcasts caught by iTunes for a week.

Ultimately all these companies are probably a lot like cell phone providers. Which is the least ugly one in the room? I wouldn’t chose at all if I didn’t have to.

I can’t believe they are telling me not to keep it now. What kind of blogosphere reaction were they expecting?

I want to make sure you know about NTEN - the Nonprofit Technology Network.

NTEN helps nonprofits learn to use the web effectively.


  • http://mtekk.weblogs.us/archives/general/looking-back-on-06/ Mtekk’s Crib » Looking Back on ‘06

    [...] Well it’s that time of year again. Christmas is over and here the (tech) world sits in the doldrums week between Christmas and New Years. A year ago several promising applications debuted, including Flock and Songbird. A year ago the entire Web 2.0 craze caught the world’s attention. A year ago the future looked bright. Today however, bleak news arrives constantly. Former heroes lack their former luster, and fear uncertainty and doubt spreads about their possible demise. Apple, amidst its cult-like following, faces scandal accusations and the fear of Steve Jobs leaving in the future. Google, on the other hand, hasn’t completely refrained from being evil in the eyes of some. Microsoft’s free Acer Ferrari laptops for selected bloggers just this week became a big conspiracy once they began asking for them back. What looked to be a promising year hasn’t fully lived up to the hype. Hopefully 2007 will grace the good people on Earth. However, hopefully 2007 will discomfiture those whom choose to make the lives of the good people unnecessarily difficult. [...]

  • http://70.32.83.183/2006/12/28/microsoft-pr-sparks-a-blogstorm-of-support-and-outrage/ Microsoft PR Sparks a Blogstorm of Support and Outrage | PR2.0

    [...] Marshall Kirkpatrick is not so impressed – “Microsoft and AMD sent out a pile of very expensive (yet trashy looking) laptops to a number of bloggers over the past week. I almost smashed mine in the middle of the street 10 minutes into trying to use it!” [...]

  • Sujit Das

    Please provide Me a laptop .

  • http://www.hicran.net ask siirleri

    rapkesh Ferhat Rapturk@hotmail.de

  • http://www.direkfilm.net sinema izle

    Why Second Life is considered “sharing” while Youtube is commercial???
    I think Second Life should be considered Commercial/RW, at least you must pay something even to upload a file in SL.. While in Youtube it is free….
    Maybe SL could be another good example of hybrid…. anyway..

  • http://www.altinkilic.com peynir

    wowww thanks you bro

  • http://www.hepizle.net snnyk
  • http://www.alimezdegi.com Estetik

    Leading companies every time Microsoft ..

  • http://www.vajinaestetik.net Vajina

    me toooo :) )))

  • http://www.arsreklam.com ars reklam

    Thanks nice, I need laptop :)

  • http://www.direkfilm.org direk film izle

    Thanks for your good website and for sharing your experiences.

  • http://www.bilgiyarismasi.biz Bilgi yarışması

    good sharing

  • http://streamdirectreview.com/ Stream Direct

    Thanks for sharing your experience with us…
    please keep posting your reviews….

  • http://www.farrellkramer.com/2006/12/29/whats-worse-than-providing-free-laptops-to-bloggers/ What’s Worse Than Providing Free Laptops to Bloggers?

    [...] Aaron has apparently been sending out in response to the flack about the giveaway. According to Marshall Kirkpatrick, it goes likes [...]

  • http://www.bizimcorum.com çorum haber

    Leading companies every time Microsoft ..

  • http://www.oyundiyari.org oyun

    Why Second Life is considered “sharing” while Youtube is commercial???
    I think Second Life should be considered Commercial/RW, at least you must pay something even to upload a file in SL.. While in Youtube it is free….
    Maybe SL could be another good example of hybrid…. anyway..

  • http://www.hakyolunda.com ilahi

    good blog really and good sharing

  • http://www.memurblog.com memur

    Thank you great post admin :)

  • http://blogobig.com/pr/unlucky_giveaway_of_notebooks_by_microsoft.html Blogobig » ??? ?? ???? ?????????? » Даровані блоґерам ноутбуки вилізли компанії Microsoft боком

    [...] відгуки щодо своїх кроків, Microsoft розіслала блоґерам додаткові листи 27 грудня, повідомивши, що ноутбук бажано або повернути або [...]

  • http://www.direkfilm.gen.tr direk film izle

    Thanks for your good website and for sharing your experiences.Thanks my friend.

  • http://www.direkfilm.gen.tr direk film izle

    Thanks for your good website and for sharing your experiences.Thanks my friend

  • http://www.gulbransen.net/2006/12/microsoft_we_ca/ Microsoft: We can’t even *give* Vista away!

    [...] bloggers a chance to preview Vista on swanked-out, fugly, yet free laptops, it turns out, Microsoft wants the laptops back. Classic. Let’s hope Microsoft executed Vista better than they’ve executed this PR [...]

  • http://www.sankomdiyet.net/ sankom diyet

    що ноутбук бажано або повернути або

  • http://www.hemorex.tk/ Hemorex

    really, I do not know what to say. But thanks so much.

  • http://www.apexbreast.tk/ Apex Breast

    Hi, How are you? Priority boarding priority effort to thank this site to friends I know in the past. You like your site is really excellent and successful. I wish you success in future work …

  • http://www.formula21.gen.tr/ Formula 21

    Hi, How are you? Priority boarding priority effort to thank this site to friends I know in the past. You like your site is really excellent and successful. I wish you success in future work …

    Best Regards …

  • http://www.nicdur.gen.tr/ Nicdur

    Hi, How are you? Priority boarding priority effort to thank this site to friends I know in the past. You like your site is really excellent and successful. I wish you success in future work …

    Best Regards …

  • http://www.biktimtoz.com/ Bıktım Tozu

    Hi, How are you?

    Life goes on. But the Web sites, updates never stops. What’s New in new systems and services every day is present. Internet under 6 hours a day by visiting the web sites, I do self assessments.

    This site is useful to see the purpose of service. But it could have been stronger than some of the issues and services. We think that Internet users spend just a good time. This hour of fun we want to learn something new.

    A request is the administrator of this site will be the best in your hand, thinking of us. Thank you for your attention. Wishing you success in your work.

    Remember, there is a statement that failure. There are just lazy. Whatever it is, plays …

    Best Regards …

  • http://www.devallkrem.org/ Devall Krem

    If serializing is prioritized over habits then won’t serialized project approach cause you to constantly work on the next group project? As project time is impossible to calculate you will eventually have to breach particular habit times.

  • http://www.yamansoft.com web tasarımı

    Excellent tips .I really appreciate all these points, and I agree completely…
    44

  • http://www.v-boomstrip.net V-Boom

    Hi, How are you?

    Life goes on. But the Web sites, updates never stops. What’s New in new systems and services every day is present. Internet under 6 hours a day by visiting the web sites, I do self assessments.

    This site is useful to see the purpose of service. But it could have been stronger than some of the issues and services. We think that Internet users spend just a good time. This hour of fun we want to learn something new.

    A request is the administrator of this site will be the best in your hand, thinking of us. Thank you for your attention. Wishing you success in your work.

    Remember, there is a statement that failure. There are just lazy. Whatever it is, plays …

    Best Regards …

  • http://www.troyler.com Troyler

    Thank you your post good sharing

  • http://www.troyler.com Troyler

    good articles your post

  • http://gOLFoCALA.org gOLF oCALA

    Microsoft is a funny little company isn’t it?

  • http://autorepairocala.org auto repair ocala

    Their OS is full of holes. Open source versions of Linux are the best for the security of your data…but then again Americans prefer McDonalds

  • http://www.atckart.com mifare kart

    thanks for your post very interesting

  • Ahmet Yilmaz

    biz buraya niye geldik

  • http://ayipbe.com/ Sikiş

    Eh simdi oldu sanirim :d

  • http://www.organicdirect.com. organic delivery service

    There are some interesting points made in this post but I don’t know if I see all of them heart to eye . There is some validity but I will take hold judgement until I look into it further. Good clause, thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner besides.

  • http://elilhaam.blogspot.com Ilham Abbas

    There are some interesting points made in this post but I don’t know if I see all of them heart to eye . There is some validity but I will take hold judgement until I look into it further. Good clause, thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner besides.

  • http://www.selfhypnosistherapy.com/conquer-fear-of-public-speaking.html speaking fear

    This is a great summary, I found your blog page browsing google for a related subject matter and came to this. I couldnt find to much additional info on this posting, so it was good to discover this one. I will be back to look at some other posts that you have another time.

  • http://www.www-trialoffers.com/enlarge-maxx-male-enlargement/ enlarge maxx

    Well written content like this today is far too rare, and thank you for putting in time and effort into your wonderful website.

  • http://www.instantsubliminal.com subliminal CD

    I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. I have read most of them and learned a lot from them. You are doing some great work. Thank you for making such a nice website.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1524242377 Michael Rubillo

    This actually makes sense to me. Microsoft couldn’t give you (the writer of the blog) the laptop. If they do it could be said they gave you compensation for your review, which in turn could have biased your review. It is the same reasoning behind why Consumer Reports can not have advertising in it. Granted this does not excuses the fact that they put some junior marketing person in charge of writing the original email to you or the fact that the original email made it out the door saying what it said.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Nesrin-Demir/100002448121384 Nesrin Demir
  • Kasas
  • http://www.roombavacuumreviewsite.com/ Roomba Vacuum

    Excellent job! Thanks for the great posting and your all efforts. I think the above article is valuable for all concerned people. At least, if was very useful for me. I’ve bookmarked this page for future reference, thank you again.

  • http://secockpitreviewz.com SeCockpit Review

    Lately, I did not give a lot of consideration to giving comments on site page posts and have placed feedback even much less. Reading through your pleasant post, will support me to do so sometimes.

  • http://www.wiiisodownload.net Wii ISO

    Wow, Thanks for the insight and the info. Never really considered these tips until I read this. Thanks a bunch. If only people would read more!

  • http://www.morethemerrier.com.au Sydney Birthday Party

    It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing. I will be very good reader and listener.

  • http://www.chatkanali.com chat kanalı
  • http://www.LifeDr.com Your Life

    Fantastic article ! You have made some very astute statements and I appreciate the the effort you have put into your writing. It’s clear that you know what you are writing about. I am excited to read more of your sites content.

  • http://electricblanketreviews.co.uk/ electric blanket

    I have to agree with many others before me, it is a very great article

  • http://www.bentoniteclay.org Great Bentonite Clay

    I have been searching for some information about it almost three hours. You helped me a lot indeed and reading this your article I have found many new and useful information about this subject. .

  • http://www.fbfanslikestore.com fb likes

    There is no better way to give information to people than on this way.The right information always find way to targeted people.I completily realize you admin.Great recourse of info. .

  • http://www.teknodium.com web tasarım

    great post very nice thanks a lot.

  • http://singaporesescorts.com/singapore-escort-services/ Singapore Escorts

    My friend recommended I will this way blog. They ended up being entirely appropriate. This specific article truly built our morning. Anyone can not think about simply the amount occasion I had created expended just for this info! Cheers!