Google’s Blog Search Thumps Yahoo!

In the last few days Yahoo! has unveiled their Blog Search Engine and lots of people have been talking about the decision to put blogs in a little box on the side of their news search results. That’s not nearly as important to me as the following:

  • Indexes: Searching for “Web 2.0” in Yahoo! blog search brings 1,300+ results. Google’s new blog search engine offers 18,000 results. Additionally, many of Yahoo’s results appear to be items from peoples’ social bookmarking archives. That’s good that those are included, but it also inflates the numbers, as both blog posts and their appearance in archives appear to be included in Yahoo’s results. Compare these numbers with Technorati’s 16,000+ results and BlogPulse’s 9,000+ results.
  • Inbound Link Search: Yahoo Blog Search does nothing to improve the disappointing state of inbound link search of the blogosphere.
  • Supporting Multi-Media: Yahoo Blog Search results under “see more blog search results” offers Flickr image results, but Technorati brings back Flickr images as well as Buzznet photos, Del.icio.us and Furl bookmark archived items. My personal favorite, Tag Central pulls from many, truly multimedia search sources.

So I’m not too impressed with Yahoo’s blog search engine yet. I’ll probably use it allong with Google Blogsearch, Technorati, PubSub, Feedster and BlogPulse, perhaps spliced together in one RSS feed per query via FeedDigest with duplicates removed.

I also think that Yahoo’s podcast directory is a bummer, if for no reason than that it appears you have to log in to a Yahoo account in order to download anything! You can listen through some proprietary Yahoo listener, but I’d like to put my podcasts on my “pod” – towards which they were cast. Much like Flickr’s new login procedure after being bought by Yahoo, it appears that the advertising we see upon visiting Yahoo isn’t enough – we must register to see even more ads. Users may as well just search inside the Libsyn directory and find plenty of easily downloadable podcasts.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

Furl Update

After writing this post complaining about Furl.net, I talked to the CTO of LookSmart, Furl’s parent company, for quite awhile this morning. It was a great conversation about the tagosphere and Furl in particular. He was very open to hearing some thoughts about increasing the usability of Furl and bringing it more in tune with the best of Web 2.0. Sounds like serious changes are already underway. At the same time, he said it was a top priority to make their service as understandable to non-geeks as possible. I think that’s a great priority, so we’ll see if we can meet somewhere in the middle. That would be best for me, too, as few of my clients are super-geeky. Teaching them to use tools that are powerful, but easy to use, is ideal.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Getting RSS Organized

D.C. non-profit technologist and awesome blogger Michael Stein wrote a very good post this week titled Bread and Butter 2.0. In it he said that most non-profit groups need more access to money and straightforward uses of their computers, not a bunch of “technology for it’s own sake.” Stein said he could see the use of AJAX right away, to increase the usability of web services non-profits are using, but asks what other Web2.0 tools really hit the bread and butter issues.

I would contend that RSS does that. Finding the right feeds to subscribe to and organizing them well is key.

If you don’t have an RSS reader yourself, you can see a demonstration account filled with feeds by going to Newsgator and logging in as user: marshalldemo password: welcome. I told Norris McDonald, the director of the African American Environmentalist Association (for whom I do blog technical support) about that demonstration RSS reader and he emailed me back saying, “Oh. I see. Very useful…Yes I can see the benefits of RSS now. I will join and use. Thanks. See why I like that you are out there.” (Thanks Norris!)

Here’s how I’m organizing my feed reader at Newsgator right now. I have wanted to write about this for awhile, but inspired by Michael Stein’s post I hope that this will be a clear demonstration of how RSS hits the bread and butter issues.

My feeds go into folders titled:

1. Reputation Tracking – who’s linking to me? search to RSS from Technorati, Pubsub, Feedster and Google Blogsearch

2. Product Vendors – if a product vendor who’s service I use posts to their blog about a planned service interruption or a new feature, then I’ll know right away. When services are back up, I’ll know that too and I won’t have to keep checking for updates.

3. Clients (or call this stakeholders) – this folder captures new blog posts from my clients, instances of someone else linking to them, emails sent to project email accounts that I don’t check regularly myself, items clients have tagged as of interest to me (or tagged at all for the infrequent taggers), notifications that any of the wikis I use to communicate with clients have been changed, and mp3 files of my brother’s radio show (just for fun)

4. Community of Practice – RSS feeds for blogs like yours, the NPTech Meta Feed, etc.

5. Thought Leaders – Feeds for A-list and other big bloggers, or innovators on whatever scale.

6. Key Industry News

7. Searches, Frequent – Feeds for searches that always get lots of new results (like for “podcasters”) and that just make interesting info channels.

8. Searches, Rare – Feeds for searches that are a big deal if and when they come up with anything, like Blinkx.com podcast search for “Blogher conference” When rare search feeds come up with results, I want to know and not to have it get lost in a larger folder.

9. Conversations – RSS feeds for comments on sites I’ve commented on, when available (like with WordPress blogs)

10. Podcasts – This is where I put my podcast feeds, I open it when I want a podcast and I see what’s newly arrived.

11. Other – this is where I put almost everything else.

Anything brand new I will plop into my reader outside all those folders, so I can watch it very closely for awhile and decide where I want to put it. All put together, this makes my RSS reader like a control panel to monitor all the actual or potential content streams of interest to me, with them organized in a way that prioritizes them according to the varying importance of seeing each item that comes through various feeds. I’m currently subscribed to 238 feeds, so without this or some other system I would go insane. There is no way I can read everything that comes down the pipe, but that’s ok. So long as I see the really important things then everything else is like my personalized cable t.v. to surf.

Finally, non-profit groups would also benefit greatly by making their own news updates and events calenders available for supporters to subscribe to via RSS. Many people would be interested enough to put an RSS feed into their feed reader to sit invisible until new items come through, but not interested enough to return to your site regularly to see if there is anything new there.

Advantages to RSS over email include:

  • Findability and tracking: Emails get lost in inboxes and junk mail folders. RSS feeds, if well organized, are way less likely to be lost. Additionally you can see how many people have actually read your items delivered via RSS through tools like Feedburner’s item click-through.
  • Security: Once your emails are sent, they are sent. There’s no bringing them back. If you decide you want to change a message delivered by RSS you can just change the text in your feed and readers will receive only the updated version when they access your feed in their feed reader.

Yes RSS is wonderful. And I think it addresses bread and butter issues. If you’ve read this far, watch for an event over at TechSoup.org in a couple of weeks that Michael Stein and I will be participating in together, little info available yet.

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Web 2.0 Poetry

Have been getting several visitors and links therefrom over the last few hours who have very interesting things to say themselves. Longer writings, pretty involved and conceptual, and quite well written.

Check out:

Some cool discussion. If you’re getting stressed out about it, I’ll go back to writing about less conceptual stuff soon.

Technorati Tags: ,